Please Don’t Buy My Book

I’m just back from The Smarter Artist Summit in Austin, Texas. I won’t try and capture the magic of the event – Kobo Mark does an excellent job – but I would like to talk about the big takeaway: the dangers of Also Bought pollution.

Also Boughts are probably the most important aspect of the entire Amazon recommendation ecostructure. And also the least understood.

They are much more than a little strip under your book’s description – they power a huge chunk of the recommendations that Amazon serves to readers.

The Also Boughts are what tells Amazon that the readers of my non-fiction also like reading Susan Kaye Quinn, Sean Platt and Johnny Truant. Amazon uses this data to decide who to recommend books to – because Amazon is always seeking to show readers the books they are most likely to purchase.

For this reason, it’s important to monitor your Also Boughts. They can really help you, but also totally break you.

Case Study #1 – Great Success!

When I first launched Let’s Get Visible, I knew it was important to have the companion book Let’s Get Digital in the #1 Also Bought spot, and vice versa, so that when one title had a sales spurt, Amazon would recommend purchasers (new and old) the other one in the set. The launch plan was simple enough: tie the Also Boughts together, push both books as hard as possible, and then sit back as they both bootstrap each other up the charts, creating an awesome feedback loop.

In detail what I did was this:

  1. Created pre-release buzz in my audience by teasing excerpts from Visible right here. These posts were accompanied by a clear CTA to get people to sign up to my list.
  2. Gave out 20 ARCs to a tightly focused group of writers in my target audience, and encouraged them to post reviews on release day.
  3. Arranged blurb quotes from experienced and successful authors who would resonate with my target audience.
  4. Wrote guest posts on targeted blogs. I deliberately didn’t go hard on this as I was more concerned with selling to purchasers of Digital at first. But for each guest post I pushed the following deal just as hard as the new release…
  5. Dropped the price of Digital to 99c for launch week, and threw a bunch of ads at it. I also had a BookBub lined up for 30 days later, to catch both books before they fell off the cliff.
  6. Made a ballsy prediction in the text of Visible along the lines of “by the time you read this, Digital will be #1 in the Also Boughts of Visible and vice versa.” This could have gone very badly wrong! Instead it made me look good. Phew.

And it worked a treat. The launch was huge, both books pushed each other higher and higher, and I think Visible had an incredible run at the upper reaches of the charts for something like 8 to 10 weeks before it even started to dip. A perfect launch – largely because my Also Boughts were pristine.

Now, I only have so much juice. I can push a launch to my list and to my social media platform. But after four or five days of hustle, it’s not me pushing the book anymore. It is word-of-mouth and its AI clone: the Amazon recommendation engine – which I always think of as a giant system for both stimulating and simulating word-of-mouth.

Had my Also Boughts been off when Amazon’s system kicked in, it would have started recommending Visible to all the wrong readers. And this isn’t just theory.

Case Study #2 – Disaster Strikes

Let’s contrast that perfect launch with the complete mess I made of Mercenary. It wasn’t a bad plan per se, or even a bad launch week. I just didn’t know enough about Also Boughts at the time. It was also your fault. Let me explain…

My first novel was quite niche, so I made an effort with Mercenary to widen the commercial appeal – i.e. this time the protagonist was American, half the book was set in New Orleans, and it was generally a little more action focused and character-driven.

As such I thought it might be a cool idea to launch at 99c, and give my writer audience a chance to sample my fiction at an impulse price. That all went to plan, I think I had something like 400 or maybe 500 sales during the four days I was pushing the book hard.

And then it flopped. It barely sold another copy for six months. Why?

Also Boughts.

My generous writer audience bought in their droves, so my Also Boughts were a mixture of writer How To books, and a crazy mix of genres: thrillers, romance, science fiction. Lots of erotica too. Just saying…

Anyway, this meant that when Amazon’s system took the temperature of my book – which it does twice a week when Also Boughts recrunch – it decide (a) this book is fairly hot. Let’s push it! And (b) let’s send it to people who like science fiction erotica about how to optimize your keywords.

Total. Fail.

Because your book is being tested by the system all time. If they send it out to 100 readers and none of them click on the cover… it’s going to stop sending it out. It’s going to decide your book is radioactive, and it’s going to push it down the rankings.

Which is exactly what happened. And then you are in a Catch-22 where you have no sales, and no reviews because no one is buying, and you can’t get an ad because you have no reviews. A death spiral of epic proportions.

What I should have done at that point was take the bull by the horns and do something radical to clean out the Also Boughts and replace them with books in my genre. I could have done a free run. I could have run a 99c sale on a handful of sites that had less strict review requirements. Hell, I would have been better off pulling the book down and publishing again.

Instead, I let it mold and fester until it eventually got enough reviews to run a decent promo – and that cleaned up the Also Boughts to a certain extent. But the book… well I don’t know if you would say it never recovered, it certainly never reached its sales potential. It was a much, much better book than A Storm Hits Valparaiso, but never brought in as much money.

Lesson learned, right? Wrong!

I took some time out after the second edition of Digital to step away from the hustle and become a better writer, not just in terms of craft, but also in terms of writing to market. I spent a lot of time analyzing tropes and archetypes, and improving my plotting skills. So I was pretty pumped when it came time to release Liberty Boy. I knew it was a good book.

So I launched it and it did… okay, I guess, considering my list was kind of stale and it had been a while since I released anything, especially a historical. But I wasn’t sweating it because I knew the book was good enough to find its audience eventually.

But then the Also Boughts didn’t appear when I expected them to. I clearly had more sales than the threshold needed for Also Boughts to appear (used to be 10, I think, and I’m pretty sure it’s 50 now). I emailed KDP and, well, you can imagine how that went. Canned responses and stonewalling. KDP customer service is just not good when it comes to complex issues.

I ended up going crazy over this, emailing Amazon the whole time, trying to get them to look at it properly. At the time (last summer), there was a huge rolling problem with Also Boughts. Authors were seeing books revert to Also Vieweds for no reason. Amazon refused to acknowledge there was an issue for ages – and it was driving people to despair, because without Also Boughts, your book is essentially invisible to the recommendation engine.

My situation was even worse because I didn’t get them at all. You might as well have deleted my book from the Kindle Store.

Now, before we get too maudlin here, I eventually solved the problem with brute force: three months after the launch, I dropped the price to 99c and kept throwing ads at the book until the Also Boughts eventually appeared (and I never did find out what the problem was).

What I should have done is cut my losses much earlier. I should have done a free run or 99c sale, or thrown some Facebook ads at the problem.

But that’s not the key point here.

What you really need to takeaway from all this is that you need to find your readers, and you need to aim your marketing at them. Exclusively.

Don’t target Action & Adventure readers when your novel is at the more literary end of the historical spectrum.

Don’t target erotic romance readers when your stuff is sweeter.

Yes, there might be some crossover, but if your Also Boughts get polluted, you will be completely screwed. And the most crucial time to avoid that is when the book is being launched, and there is no long history of your target readers, the right readers, buying your book.

When we start out, we’re desperate for sales. We’re over the moon when our mother purchases our debut, or when that guy in work picks up a copy, even though he’s more into thrillers. But that is killing your book – especially if it happens before you develop a sales history with the right readers.

Those people can buy later, just not at the start, not while your book is still new, and it’s baby-head is still soft. And certainly not before you get Also Boughts.

I’ll be talking a lot more about this subject over the next few weeks, as it ties into everything. And it’s like the indie movement has gone full circle . From the Buy My Book cliché to demurring:

“Please don’t buy my book.”

I mean it!

About David Gaughran

David is Irish and lives in Dublin, where it rains every day and conversation is a sport. He writes historical adventures and has helped thousands of authors to self-publish through his workshops, books, and this here blog.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

37 Responses to Please Don’t Buy My Book

  1. authorcpatt says:

    Too late, I already mucked up Liberty Boy…

    Like

  2. Reblogged this on Gabriella West and commented:
    Happy Spring! Ever thought about Amazon’s also-boughts and how it affects your writing sales? Author David Gaughran shares his experiences.

    Like

  3. Reblogged this on Ruth Nestvold – Indie Adventures and commented:
    David Gaughran is back, with an interesting case study on also-boughts.

    Like

  4. That’s really interesting. I never even thought to consider the also boughts.

    Like

  5. Bill Peschel says:

    Thanks for going into detail about this. I’ve heard about dealing with the also bots, but this is the first time I’ve seen a concrete plan. And “Liberty Boy” is still suffering from it, since I see a western (which is what I thought LB was judging from the cover), a contemporary Brit mystery, your multi-pack, and a serial killer thriller. Even more bizarre, the sponsored ads are for “50 Shades” type “romance.” Your book seems to appeal to a diverse audience.

    Like

  6. Yeah it’s a giant pain. Having no also boughts for three months was like attaching rocks to the book and tossing it in the lake. The only way I could get any at all – with few reviews and none on the horizon – was a rather scattergun 99c ad approach. Which left me with sub-par also boughts. I’ll need to take care of it eventually, hopefully with the next promo – I just haven’t pushed anything in forever while on an extended break.

    The sponsored ads are another matter. That’s authors employing (I’m guessing) a crazily broad approach to targeting which will do them no favors at all. Amazon’s ad system doesn’t seem to build in any real penalties for that (unlike say AdWords), but they will torch their money and possibly pollute their also boughts as well.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. acflory says:

    Reblogged this on Meeka's Mind and commented:
    As a reader, I do look at ‘Also Boughts’ in my never-ending quest to find new, favourite sci-fi authors. But…as a writer? -face palm-
    Thanks for a great post, David. I’ll be doing some serious thinking as a result.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Reblogged this on Author/Journalist Jessica Samuels and commented:
    Definitely, something to keep in mind for the future!

    Like

  9. MELewis says:

    This post is like a mini-marketing course. Lots of lessons here – I’m in! (Hope I don’t mess up the WP ‘also-followed’s’? 😉 Thanks to Meeks (Meeka’s Mind) for bringing me here!

    Like

    • Thanks. I’m back blogging after a long break and I’m going to kick off with a bunch of marketing posts, all centred around related topics. In fact, I’ve come up with a whole new approach to marketing and I’m writing a book on it, and this is a way of kind of fleshing out some of the concepts. I’m going to dig into a bunch of stuff over the next few weeks and I hope you find it useful.

      Liked by 2 people

  10. Interesting case-studies, thanks David. How do Amazon ads affect this whole scene, if at all.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Most definitely the subject of a future post, but the same golden rule applies: find out who your Ideal Readers are, target them exclusively. A broader approach will come back to bite you. (And it doesn’t matter if someone is making the mistake of being broad and targeting your pages – doesn’t affect you at all.)

      Liked by 1 person

  11. Poor baby… It is not about purchasing your book, it was just a survival reflex that was inside you. Make that money honey 😉

    Like

  12. Pingback: Who’s Pointing At You? | David Gaughran

  13. Jake Parent says:

    Recently, I had my first Bookbub promo, and while it was of course great that the book sold enough to make my money back and distribute 1000’s of copies, plus provide an accompanying boost to organic traffic, the much more interesting result has been a drastic increase in the effectiveness of my AMS ads. It now seems much easier to get steady impressions and thus scale.

    The whole Bookbub push has been a huge eye-opener for me in regard to thinking of Amazon as a giant recommendation system.

    Glad to have found this piece.

    Like

  14. jjtoner says:

    Very interesting. Seems to me you need a series of, say, 3 books that will link to one another naturally as also-boughts.

    Like

  15. Pingback: Saturday Morning News Briefs | Diane Tibert

  16. Pingback: Boksläpp, besviken läsare, bokklubb och branding | Förverkliga din bokdröm

  17. A very informative and important article. Thank you.

    Like

  18. Pingback: Wiing Links 5/8/17 – Where Genres Collide

  19. Pingback: Episode 162 – Fake News, Buy Boxes, and Activating Fans | Sell More Books Show

  20. Reblogged this on Republic of Adventures and commented:
    Nice thoughts about it and he is true. Target the right readers from the beginning on, even when the niche won’t hit the big. Selling steadily is better than no selling.

    Like

  21. Pingback: Best of the Blogs: 13 May 2017

  22. Pingback: ‘Also Bought’ by David Gaughran | Lonely Power Poles

  23. Pingback: Writer Wednesday | creative barbwire (or the many lives of a creator)

  24. Pingback: Amazon Has A Fake Book Problem | David Gaughran

  25. Pingback: Useful Link Round-up – Kit Campbell Books

  26. Pingback: Useful Link Round-up | Where Landsquid Fear to Tread

  27. Richard M says:

    The challenge I found in using BookBub was that it notably changed my “also bought” section. This makes sense since many BookBub readers will probably buy the books promoted by them, but it means the books that appear in my “also bought” section are totally wild and random. Ironically, it did not affect my sales of my other books that appears formerly in my “also bought” section. Perhaps because my book is now appearing in the “also bought” section of many other books now.

    Like

    • Yes, your Also Boughts can certainly get scrambled after a BB (or any major promo) – another reason why it’s good to focus on your own core readers first before broadening your marketing. In my case, the Also Boughts were in such terrible shape that ones slightly outside the ideal would be a vast improvement so I was happy to roll that dice, and they are looking much healthier now, if not quite my dream also boughts. But I’m working on ways of tieing more useful books to that title, and I’ll talk about the options there in another post at some point.

      Like

    • And as you rightly point out, it’s actually the books pointing at you which are more important (the ones in your also bought section merely act as an indicator of which might be pointing at you). More on that in this post, in case you didn’t see it: https://davidgaughran.wordpress.com/2017/05/05/whos-pointing-at-you/

      Like

  28. Pingback: When Reader Targeting Goes Wrong | David Gaughran

Release Your Word-Minions!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s